This was a sporty posting

Sep 28, 2014,07:51 AM
 

BMW make nice cars...although my mind is very open to many other brands too.
But firstly, allow me to quote/copy your text almost in100% detail smile

"It's amazing what BMWs can do.
hey drive so incredibly well on twisty and windy mountain roads that I sometimes think
(here come the letters from my readers) I wouldn't need a Porsche, the BMW 3-series handles so well
and so subliminally that it's simply not necessary to have a Porsche. 
Plus, BMWs are usually significantly larger than Porsches, so they're more practical and safer
in every day usage and shopping runs.  Yes, a BMW fulfills my wants and my needs. 
But why do I still want a Porsche?  I guess that's a deep conversation that I
should probably have with a psychiatrist or other professional help."

Now, I have no experience from the 3-series, M (or any lower-styled) BMW's really, but apart from that - I agree 100% with you.

So...
we like to sit a bit high, and all the cars we have had in the recent years, quite a few,  have been of some kind of SUV -type.
(But a short-lived BMW X1 a few years ago, was simply too small and uncomfortable for me - it almost killed my back).

Now, I really like BMW -  there is "something" about them and we have decided to give the brand one more chance.
We recently settled on and picked up this - the new F15 - but it had really a hard competition by the new Porsche Macan in our case.


The BMW draw the longest straw - as it was hard to beat out of practical reasons, like space, easy for serviceability (many dealers carries the brand) - superb fuel usage (in our case Diesel) - and simply - every day usage.
The Macan - also a great car and much more sporty in it's behavior - would be quite much smaller. The Cayenne was also a contender - but as of the 2014 model - it can't really catch up with many of BMW's fancy and "nice to have" techies. Now - I do think this will change - or at least the gap narrows down soon. As as you mentioned initially...my mind keeps on thinking about a Porsche too.

Love the X5 interior lighting too. All kind of color-combinations from orange- blue and white possible to set up.


This is really a "poor mans X5" as I tell everyone who asks - because it got the smallest engine BMW adapts to it as of now (211PS).
That said - it pulls amazingly good. Surprisingly well really to be honest. I believe this must partly be honored to the extremely capable 8-speed transmission too.

Ooh, but you asked about a favorite BMW smile

My answer should therefore be, in our case, "X5", right?
Well, yes - for now I must say X5, but wow, the X4 is just out, and the new X6 is on it's way. The X6 surely could be interesting too.
Now, I do not believe that any of these two - will have the practicality of the X5 finally - so I try to keep my mind cool a bit more.
I really do have the "feel good" feeling inside - each time I step (up) into our  X5 cockpit smile

Thanks for your interesting post,

Best
Bent


More posts: BMWCayennePorsche

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

BMWs, Airstrips, and Kilowatts, Oh My! What's your favorite BMW?

 
 By: patrick_y : September 26th, 2014-18:53
PuristSPro moderator Patrick_y gets a quick look and test drive of some BMWs on the airstrip and in the real world. I have a thing for cars. And especially German cars. And BMWs are one of my personal favorites. I like BMWs so much, that I actually own an...  

BMW has always been my favorite manufacturer.

 
 By: JerryW : September 26th, 2014-21:14
Just not sure why I have not owned one since 2007 although my favorite was my 1994 850Ci. JerryW

How do you like the BMW i8?

 
 By: patrick_y : September 27th, 2014-11:48
Would an i8 look good in your garage? It'd be very green.

I will wait a while before I decide if I like Hybrids.

 
 By: JerryW : September 27th, 2014-21:10
For now I want 8, 10 or 12 cylinders pumping out a great sound. A few garage updates are on the way, should be interesting. JerryW

Over the last 10 years

 
 By: dedestexhes : September 26th, 2014-22:29
My wife and I had 7 BMW's (1, 3 and 5 series often with 6cyl engines)... So suppose we like them ;-) The most fun was a 130i. Always have loved their ride compared to the other cars in the segment. Having said that, never owned a BMW M. Although I think t... 

Really hard to say...

 
 By: patrick_y : September 27th, 2014-11:56
Keep in mind, when the designers build these things; the design of certain BMWs have aged well though. My favorite, the E39 5-series has aged fairly well. I still like it when I see it on the road. In fact, I wouldn't mind owning a 2002-2003 530i in perfe... 

interesting question about the E92

 
 By: dedestexhes : September 27th, 2014-12:11
Btw, I love the sound of that engine, getting to a kind of metalic tone... I think the design is nice, the problem is just that as soon as the new model is there, obviously the price collapses, which is not as such a problem. However, that attracks a kind... 

Ahh, I see...

 
 By: patrick_y : September 27th, 2014-12:22
Underworld car... Hmm... I still love the E92 M3. And would love to own one. You mentioned you and your wife like the 6-cylinder BMWs. Would this be your first V8?

Yes it would be

 
 By: dedestexhes : September 27th, 2014-12:26
We have also the DB7 Vantage, a 12 cyl. So it would be nice to add an 8 cyl high reving engine. But then again, as stated in a previous thread, also thinking about th Porsche 997 GT3. Disadvantage being the fact that it is limited for daily use, 2 childre... 

We have some PuristSPro members with the M3 and C63...

 
 By: patrick_y : September 28th, 2014-01:15
All of the PuristSPro members whom come to mind have two children who have the C63 and the M3 seem to make it work quite well with their families. They're all exciting cars.

I love the 6 Coupé a lot. Sadly, too big for my parking.

 
 By: amanico : September 26th, 2014-23:49
But the line is awesome, and I am convinced that the engines are top. The new 4 series is very intersting and pleases me a lot. The line of the body is even more balanced than the 3, in my opinion. But would the engine of the M4 be as exciting as the M3??... 

The M4 engine isn't as exciting as the M3!

 
 By: patrick_y : September 27th, 2014-12:09
Starting with the 650i. That was a very luxurious car, felt much more like a BMW 7 series than a BMW 5 series. Even though I think it has a 5 series chassis. The quietness, the smoothness of the suspension (it felt more like an air suspension), and the lu... 

Yes, was thinking a lot of getting one M 3 8 Cyl, or even the former 6 Cyl...

 
 By: amanico : September 27th, 2014-13:30
Man, the driving pleasure was there! I am a bit afraid it get lost, with the new M4, COMPARED to the former M3s... Best, Nicolas

The former 6 cylinder...

 
 By: patrick_y : September 28th, 2014-01:09
The former E46 6-cylinder M3 is a nice car to drive. I really liked the steering on that car and the handling. That one has an even more metallic sound in the exhaust. The only issue I have with the E46 is the seating position is a bit too far to the outs... 

If I am offered the opportunity, I will do so, with great pleasure.

 
 By: amanico : September 28th, 2014-01:28
Still, I prefer the manual gear box of the BMW.... If I am not wrong, the C 63 only comes with an automatic gear box, doesn't it? Best, Nicolas

Correct.

 
 By: patrick_y : September 28th, 2014-01:48
No C63 for you, since you prefer a manual. Try the E92 M3 V8 with the DCT Double-clutch transmission. That thing is FANTASTIC! I love that gearbox. No clutch pedal, but all the control, all the engagement, and ... what can I say... It's perfect! Did I men... 

This was a sporty posting

 
 By: BentN : September 28th, 2014-07:51
BMW make nice cars...although my mind is very open to many other brands too. But firstly, allow me to quote/copy your text almost in100% detail :-) "It's amazing what BMWs can do. hey drive so incredibly well on twisty and windy mountain roads that I some...  

Thanks for reading Bent!

 
 By: patrick_y : September 28th, 2014-10:32
For me, the Porsche Macan is a perfect size; I don't need the size of the huge X5 (unless I am taking passengers all the time) so the X3 or the Porsche Macan or the Audi SQ5 would be a great size for me. In America, it is becoming more and more of a neces... 

Right now, the 4 door BMW M6 Grand Coupe

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : September 28th, 2014-13:54
BMW had a Ultimate Driving Experience here this past week where they showcased the 6, 7, and M cars. We didn't get to drive them on an empty airstrip but only on the local roads around the restaurant venue. I've test driven the M6 Grand Coupe before and t... 

Is there only a 4 doors Grand Coupé, or does a 2 doors version exist?

 
 By: amanico : September 28th, 2014-14:07
For me, a coupé with 4 doors is a blasphemy. ;) Best, Nicolas

There's the regular 2 door 6-series coupe

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : September 28th, 2014-14:12
but BMW calls the 4 door version the Gran Coupe. - AT

Logical. 4 Doors = Grand Coupé. 2 Doors = Coupé.

 
 By: amanico : September 28th, 2014-14:15
Still in a purist way, I Wonder how they can call a 4 doors car a coupé... ;) Best, Nicolas

Mercedes calls their CLS a 4 door coupe too :)

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : September 28th, 2014-14:18
So BMW isn't the only one. Nowadays, coupe is just basically referring to the shape of the car instead of only being a 2-door only term. Brands are slowly twisting the definition around :) - AT

+2, All too true, but 2-doors do not a Coupe make.

 
 By: BDLJ : September 29th, 2014-20:45
...otherwise, we'd call a 1954 Beetle a coupe, no? The whole concept is muddied and was never particularly clear in the first instance. For a long time, it has just been used to describe 2-door with ‘sporty’ lines. Which could be interpreted as just as mu... 

The 6 series grand coupe is cool...

 
 By: patrick_y : September 29th, 2014-02:36
That rear seat is kind of weird. And what's weirder is the roof. The roof doesn't open, but it does tilt to vent. Also, no grab handles on the ceiling. But that M6 looks nice! I'd like mine in Singapore Grey. I really like the deep recess in the front bum... 

My favorite BMW ?

 
 By: bimbeano : October 1st, 2014-13:53
Must be the E30 M3 Evolution i guess ... but i would be pretty happy with a first series 130i ... or the 1M off course .... . But then there's the Z3 M Coupé .... :-) From the current BMW range i like the 1-series, the 2-series (coupe), 3 and 4 series, ev... 

Saw your favorite (and more) yesterday...

 
 By: patrick_y : October 5th, 2014-10:05
Saw all of your favorites yesterday (except a 2-series and the E30 M3 wasn't an Evolution model) and in addition saw two 2002s and an E36 M3 Evolution as well. I'd like to try driving a 235i with Bilsteins and lightweight wheels too... My favorite has bee...